Tony’s Music Review of Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi
Well here it is at last, the most awaited soundtrack of 2009. Salim and Suleiman composed Rab Ne Bana Do Jodi. Shah Rukh Khan stars with a new leading lady and his good old friend Aditya Chopra directs. I decided to write a review of the soundtrack as I listened to the songs for the first time. And this is what I came up with…
01. Tujh Mein Rab Dikhta Hai (Roopkumar Rathod) Click here to listen to the song This song starts the soundtrack and is probably the best song I have heard this year. Immacualte lyrics that hit your heart immediately and the music… is very catchy. Roopkumar Rathod is an unusual choice of singer for a Shah Rukh Khan song, but I have to admit, he does indeed perform well. As per the film’s Punjabi theme, a singer with a Punjabi sounding voice was required and Rathod fits the bill. The backing female singers sound sexy. And the film’s title Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi is heard during the middle and towards the end. Song of the year! Rating: 9/10
02. Haule Haule (Sukhwinder Singh) Click here to listen to the song Sukhwinder Singh has sung this superbly but there is an overdose of the Haule Haule. Once more the song is of a Punjabi theme hence another hard sounding vocal requirement. Backing vocals are a let down. They irritate more than they sing. Sukhiwinder seems to be trying a little too hard. I would have preffered Sonu Nigaam to have sung this one as he would have brought something different to the song. The music arrangement is very good, the only terrific thing about this song. Somehow I don’t think this song will work and should certainly not have been used as an introduction to the film. Rating: 4/10
03. Dance Pe Chance (Sunidhi Chauhan, Labh Janjua) Click here to listen to the song Sunidhi Chauhan is the main singer of this song and does indeed sing well. But, she tries to be Punjabi on a disco themed song, which doesn’t work at all. The combination of Sunidhi and a voice that I have not heard before, Labh Janjua doesn’t mix. But, saying that maybe the whole idea of the song is for a difference and not a mix. Lyrics are average but the music arrangement is pretty good. My feeling is that this song might work once it is seen on the screen. Rating: 6/10
04. Phir Milenge Chalte Chalte (Sonu Nigaam) Click here to listen to the song Phir Millenge is the only track on the soundtrack with the vocals of Sonu Nigaam, and it is a huge disappointment. This song uses lines from classic songs that don’t fit in well. Aditya Chopra did say that Shah Rukh Khan has a song in the film in which he pays tribute to the greats of Indian cinema, and this song is that. The song might sound a bit odd listening to it first time, but I believe once it is thrown on the big screen it will create magic. Because of the star power the song has in it, Kajol, Rani Mukherjee and Priyanka Chopra to name a few. Sonu sings like he has only a day to live, he really should have spent a little more time on practising the vocals. However, there is no other male singer around that could have pulled this song of. Sonu mixes his voice to suit the singer he is impersonating very comicly. The lyrics are the pulling power of the song and have been done well. A lot of thinking and brains have gone into it. The music, well what can you say about that… it’s nothing new… it’s a mix of old classic numbers with nothing new to add. The highlight of the song is Rajesh Khanna’s famous dialogue. That is a must listen. The second best song on the soundtrack so far. Can this do for Rab Ne Bana Di Jodi what Deewangi did for Om Shanti Om… No! Rating: 7/10
05. Tujh Mein Rab Dikhta Hai (Shreya Ghoshal) Click here to listen to the song The female version of the first track, which is also going along as the title song of the soundtrack, is sung absulotly to perfection by Shreya Ghoshal. But why is it only 1.43 minutes long? Where is the rest of the song? This could have become the hit number of 2008 yet there is no length to it. What is the thinking behind only a short song? I would have given this song a 10/10 rating had it been longer. Rating: 8/10
06. Dancing Jodi (Instrumental) Click here to listen to the song The final track on the soundtrack is an instrumental dance number. No vocals apart from Sunidhi Chauhan trying to get in. And nothing much to write about. Just a mix of tunes from the rest of the tracks. The track sounds out of place in the album and is the most hated (by me). Seems as though a quick-fire job by the music directors to make up the now standard 6 tracks on the CD. I found it hard to listen to hence cut it of during the middle. Rating: 2/10
So there you have it. The most awaited album of the year and a major letdown. Firstly, no Abhiijeet, no Udit Narayan and not enough of Sonu Nigaam. And where was the great Lata Mangeshkar. Secondly, not enough songs. Only 3 unique tracks, one mix of old classics, one quarter of a song, and an instrumental number that has no purpose. This was supposed to be Salim-Suleiman’s biggest ever music composition and they have let us down. We wanted more songs, we didn’t get them. The whole soundtrack sounds as though it has been put together as a rush job within a week. I now fear the same has been done with the film, made in a rushed manner, and could very much be the disaster of 2008. Compared to Dilwale Dulhania Le Jaayenge and Mohabbatein this is… well it just cant be compared to them at all. Overall Rating: 6/10
Now what do you make of this soundtrack… we would love to read your reviews on the songs… do you agree with Tony or do you think that he is wrong… do you believe that this is the best soundtrack of 2009… or do you feel letdown… whatever your thoughts we would love to read them… please use the commentssection below to send them to us…
|
Haule Haule 4/10??
LOOOOL
should of had udit narayan in the songs..
well i have to listen to them all first,
but just seeing 3 proper songs only
is a disapointment, also no lata and udit!!!!!!
what were they thinking!!!
the haule haule advert took time to grow on me,
but now i really like it.
i’m sure if i had heard it before seeing it,
i would have just pressed fast forward.
The only thing that interests me is
shahrukhs new look, the girl looks
boring too!
BEAUTIFUL AND SPLENDID SONGS
SRK ROCKS
SUPER DUPPER BLOCKBUSTER
THE SONGS ARE MAGNIFICIENT
DEFINITELY SONGS OF THE YEAR
that tony gay is chattin crap a herd the songs and trust me it is the best album of the year without a doubt. all the songs are absolutely magnificent.
i really like all songs tony you are wrong
tony ko songs ke bare mein kuch bi pata nahi
haule haule- 4/10???
ROFL. thts funny
songs r good tho
TOTALLY SUPER HIT SONG
THANKS SRK
HAULE HAULE IS THE BEST 10/10
BIGGEST SONG OF THE YEAR
SINGH IS KINNG WAS THE BEST BEFORE RBNDJ RELEASE
SORRY TONY AND THANKS SRK
beautiful songs
rbndj very big!!!
best album of salim-sulaiman
best song of the year way to go. guys i think tony just does it to make us all pissed he know himself how to love srk he does himself too jsut he loves it people go crazy on him. k tony i talked for u this time beta, next time plz be lil decent for srk specially yash raj camp movie keep in mind. lol
Well, When did u write something gud abt SRK or his films??????????? So shut up!!!
By the way, I wish Udit Narayan had sung one or two, I dont like Sonu much cos he cries more than singing
poor tony.. got bashed
i agree with tony for most of it except haule haule, 4/10? come on..
yeah not enough song.. we want more..
i like all songs shahrukh nobody can beat you.
hey boys and girls…i would like to know who is this tony…is he a critics…or he is jelous of SRK writing this knida review..or he dont know about music…anyways i think its a sweeet and melodies album..and ita SRK & YRF film and this combo will work ..no doubts…it looks like punjabi style of family film….anyways good luck again to srk and yrf
[...] work and should certainly not have been used as an introduction to the film. Rating: 4/10 03.[COLOR=#00C800 ! important][COLOR=#00C800 ! important][/color][/color]Dance pe Chance (Sunidhi Chauhan, Labh Janjua) Sunidhi Chauhan is the main singer of this song and [...]
superhit songs
i never thought i would agree with tony bustard guy but he’s right. these songs are nowhere near mohabbatein and ddlj classics. adi rushed it and it shows.
What a great song collectiion by Adi and compossing by salim-Sulaiman all songs is super and touchable songs and i think this album will be biggest blockbuster music and movie of the year 2008 no doubt.
My Review & Rating 100/100
blockbuster
I did suggest to Yashraj Films that they should atleast have one duet – the title song in the voices of Lata Mangeshkar and either Sonu or Udit. I suggested that since Lataji hardly sings any more , just one song in a duet in her voice would have been great. Lataji has given many memorable romantic duets hits for Yashraj Films in the past. DDLJ had the popular Tujhe Dekha To and Mohabbatein had the still popular Humko Humise Churalo. Aditya was directing RNBJ a prestigious production after many years. Surely they could have used Lataji and Udit. Udit has also given so many hits for them.